How to buy the book

You can order at History Press as well as Amazon, Barnes and Noble and other on-line retailers. I will send you a signed copy for $23, a little extra to cover shipping. I will send you both Slave Labor in the Capital and Through a Fiery Trial for $40. Send a check to me at PO Box 63, Wellesley Island, NY 13640-0063.

My lectures at Sotterley Plantation in St. Mary's County, Maryland, on September 23, 2015, and the DAR Library on December 5 are now blog posts below listed under book talks. The talk I gave
at the Politics and Prose Bookstore on February 28, 2015, along with Heather Butts, author African American Medicine in Washington, was taped by the bookstore. Take a listen.
Showing posts with label carters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label carters. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2015

Commissioner Johnson solved problems with slaves

"The commissioners blamed Cooke and Brent for making deliveries after the hired slaves were sent home for the year."

quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 83

"The commissioners placed their next ad in the fall of 1794, angling for sawyers to work through the winter just as Hoban wanted."
quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 102

I should have written Commissioner Thomas Johnson because in the record, it appears that Johnson was alone when those decisions were made. Indeed the hand writing in the official record is Johnson's not the usual clerk's. Usually at least two of the three commissioners signed such orders.

I think this one page in the record, written by Johnson, bares his approach to work in the city. The nagging problem of amassing building materials to put in the hands of skilled workers was best solved by the use of slaves. True, the first order objects to stone deliveries after the "discharge of laborers hired by the year," but that reflects the reality. All the laborers were not slaves.

The last item on the page is a draft for a help wanted ad. It makes no mistake about the nature of the help wanted: "a number of slaves to labor in the brick yards and stone quarries for whom generous wages will be given." Not "to whom" but "for whom." Masters stood to profit not the slaves doing the work.

In the fall of 1794, getting tree trunks sawed into lumber had been a problem for almost two years. Judging from this ad, the commissioners realized that in Maryland slaves did most of the sawing. The commissioners did not like to recognize that slaves had skills. They hired them to keep down the price of labor and didn't want slave masters to think they could get more money out of them. This ad does not explicitly say "slave sawyers," but coupling sawyers with laboring slaves makes pretty clear that the audience for the ad was masters, not free workers. It also showed that grudgingly the commissioners realized that slaves had at least one skill warranting a higher wage.




Saturday, April 11, 2015

The commissioners' slave hire end-game

"Of course the slaves Mrs. Adams saw were not yearly hires from St. Mary's and Charles Counties. That was the old system. Shortly after ending that system, the commissioners realized they had gone too far and began hiring slaves on a piecemeal basis, for short terms and in small numbers compared to the old system."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, pages 155-156


In my book I focus on the systematic use of slave labor as playing an essential role in the building of the White House and Capitol which began in the summer of 1792 and ended by 1800. After clearing trees, moving and raising building stones and roofs were the slaves' essential service and they did that without causing much complaint and at little cost to the commissioners. After all the stone was raised on both the Capitol and White House, far fewer slaves were hired so that I think it fair to say that there work was no longer as essential. The 12 slaves Abigail Adams saw clearing rubbish in November 1800 were neither essential nor part of the slave hire system that entailed housing, feeding and providing medical care for slaves that the commissioners ended by 1800.

That said, the letter below suggests that the commissioners certainly did not share my view of the matter in the summer of 1800. In it they roundly condemn a master who "clandestinely" took away "a negro man" he had hired out to the commissioners on January 1.

As anyone who reads my book will see, I am skeptical of the posturing of the commissioners. Taken at face value the letter suggests that the commissioners kept an eye on the hired slaves. That is not likely. They had fired Elisha Williams who had hired slaves since 1792 and there is no evidence that the commissioners stooped to do what Williams had done for them. At his time the commissioners had lost control over much of the work to Secretary of the Navy Stoddert. Threatening to sue a man who had retrieved his slave was something still in their power and a way to show their importance.

The master was not in some far off plantation, but one of their contractors, a carter. His removing his slave could have been the upshot over a dispute over payment. But other than a receipt for his work which I share in another post, I have found out little about him save that the commissioners' did pay him for several months of slave hire in 1800, not for a whole year, and according to the 1800 census he may not have been counted as owning a slave when the census was taken. I say "may not" because while there was no Prather counted, Zephk Frather was marked as having no slave. Perhaps he sold his slave. Perhaps because the slave was hired out, Frather/Prather didn't claim ownership and avoided a tax on the slave.

The only other letter I found from the commissioners to a master who removed his slave, two slaves in that case, was markedly different. They were amenable as long as the master replaced the slaves. I share that letter in another post.

The commissioners in that earlier letter were more sure of themselves in part because they had so many slaves working for them and doing good work. In the letter to Prather, they were venting their spleen as they were losing control of the project and control over free workers who found Secretary Stoddert more sympathetic to their needs. Losing a hired slave when they had so few enraged them. Those large crews of slaves had been their way to check the demands of free workers.



Sunday, April 5, 2015

Public carts probably manned by hired slaves

"...the commissioners still maintained what were known as 'public carts,'...."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 83

Well, I think they did. I found no payrolls for carters but I think that means that laborers manned the carts probably to do both the heavy lifting and drive the carts. This letter from Lewis Deblois written in 1796 suggests that. He asks to commissioners to send an overseer and a "public cart" to retrieve some stolen lumber. There are payrolls for overseers and they were invariably called overseers of the laborers.

This letter is also interesting because it accuses Alexander Leslie, an associate of Daniel Carroll of Duddington, the main land owner on Capitol Hill, of the thefts. Evidently at that time there was no knee jerk racist reaction of blaming blacks for any thefts.

The letter also shows that despite the many slaves in the area getting work done was not as simple as whipping them into line.

In the 1800 census Daniel Carroll is listed as owning 25 slaves. The bridges to make Pennsylvania Avenue east of the Capitol passable were made of logs that came from Carroll. We can easily imagine Carroll's slaves cutting, preparing and delivering the logs. Or can we? Deblois writes "but for the want of 150 dollars (which would complete the bridges) the cost of the logs with the labor of hauling and laying will shortly be lost." That suggests that the project stopped once there was no money to pay workers evidently mostly, if not all, common laborers. The commissioners could not spare theirs nor could Carroll spare his without more money.

Deblois owned a store served by the avenue and the letter was probably as much to remind the commissioners to finish the project as it was to save the logs. However, there was a remarkable degree of distrust between land owners and the commissioners and between fellow land owners. I hope my book Through a Fiery Trial makes that apparent. The number 59 written on top of the photocopy of the letter I scanned refers to the chapter in an early draft of that book that used the info in Deblois's letter. The snarling between land owners is actually developed in chapter 60. You can get a taste of William Tunnicliff's rivalry with Deblois in this blog post.



Saturday, April 4, 2015

Horses and hauling contractors

"One contractor supplied wagons drawn by four horses at four dollars a day, two horse carts for two dollars a day and a single horse cart for ten shillings a day."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capitol, pages 80, 81

That contractor was Joseph Dove and the source of that information about carts was a March 31, 1800, letter that he wrote to the commissioners which I scanned below. The reason for the letter was to ask for more money since the cost of food had doubled since those rates for hiring wagons were established in 1793.

The commissioners' records have many letters that invite a page or two of commentary which I couldn't expound in the book. I noted the information in this letter mainly because it is one of the few references to horses used in the city and I thought it important to establish that horses were there to do the hauling essential to getting building materials to the building sites. 

If Dove had complained that the higher cost of living made it more difficult to feed his slaves as well as his horses, I would have made much more of the letter, but he didn't. The simple reason for that may well be that he didn't use slaves. According to the 1800 census Dove owned 3 slaves, but his household had 5 white children 10 years old or younger so those slaves may have been house servants under his wife's orders and not on Joseph Dove's work crew.

It is easy to assume that as the city grew more whites began to rely on slaves, but Dove's letter reminds us of the inflation at the time that added to the burden of owning slaves doing non-agricultural work. The cost of feeding them rose while, as Dove points out, what they earned for their master remained the same. So assuming Dove struggled just to get by on the short term, he might have preferred hiring free laborers as needed rather than spend the capital, which he probably didn't have, to buy an able bodied slave that he would have to feed every day as long as he owned him.


Thursday, March 19, 2015

William O'Neale letter on unloading stone

"O'Neale thought much of the shifting around was pointless. He told the commissioners that the wharves should be modified so that the wagons carrying the stone away could be placed so that the crane at the wharf could load the stone directly onto them."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 81

The letter William O'Neale wrote to the commissioners in September 1794 is interesting on several levels.  Primarily it's interesting because it is our best description of how the stone was unloaded and hauled away. The letter also gives the impression that working arrangements had not been well thought out. Plus, perhaps there was some confusion about who was in charge. O'Neale wrote to the commissioners who had no experience in such matters, not to James Hoban or Collen Williamson who did. 

Finally, O'Neale came to the city as a young Irish emigrant who knew about quarrying building stone. He wound up many years later as the proprietor of the Franklin House, a favorite inn and boarding house for politicians. He would eventually own 17 slaves. The laborers he bossed as they unloaded stone in 1794 may have been the first time he worked with slaves. The letter gives the impression that he was not impressed with the laborers and how they were employed. He doesn't mention the race of the laborers. They were either slaves or Irish. That O'Neale described them as skulking suggests to me that he was showing his disdain for slaves. He probably would have used a more forgiving word if Irishmen were involved.

As far as I know, the commissioners didn't respond to O'Neale. At the end of the year they insisted that the contractors they bought stone from bear the responsibility of getting the stone to the building sites.





Thursday, January 1, 2015

1800 receipt for hauling laborers' camps

"In December 1794 a contractor was paid to haul five logs to the 'laborers' camp on Capitol Hill.' In 1800, when slave hire ended, a man was paid to haul the 'camps' off Capitol Hill and it took his crew and wagon two days to do it."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 26

In doing my research I couldn't afford to photocopy everything so I can't show the commissioners' order sending five logs to the laborers' camp. I did photocopy a letter the commissioners sent showing the logs were used to make huts. They asked Captain Williams, the man who hired and supplied laborers, to sell the logs of a roofless hut.
 

No one ever described the camps or huts the laborers lived in but there is a receipt for what was paid to a hauler to remove them from Capitol Square:


 

It strikes me as interesting that these were called the laborers camps, and not associate particularly with "Negroes", the word almost always use to denote a slave in the commissioners' records. I think that these camps housed both white and black, free and slave laborers. In 1796 the commissioners' surveyor made a map of Notley Young's plantation along the Potomac and noted that "Houses occupied by Negro's" were colored black on the map. 

One would like better evidence but I think we obliged to use what we have. As I mention in the book, in the 1790s the powers that be did not feel compelled to enforce segregation in the lower classes.

The other items in this short receipt are interesting too. The first and fifth help us mark when the commissioners and superintendent decided work on the Capitol and progressed enough so that carpenters could concentrate on finishing the interior of the White House. Also note that while the benches and old carpenters' shop were taken to the President's House Square, no destination is noted for the camps. It took 1 1/4 days to haul the work benches, 2 days to haul the old camps, and 3 3/4 days to haul the carpenters' shop. Can that help up us estimate the size of the camps? The carpenters shop was where teams of up to six pairs of sawyers cut lumber as well as where carpenters built what ever could be pre-assembled before installation in the building. Much of the winter work was done there so it could accommodate upwards of 30 men as they worked. In 1798 the commissioners hired upwards of 120 laborers. Judging from how quickly they were hauled away my guess is that the camps the laborers slept in were not extensive. If they had been someone might have described or at least noticed them.

Items three and four, hauling Spanish whiting and lime, show how calcium carbonate and calcium hydroxide were brought together for the men doing the plastering to use. That the lime came from Dr. May is intriguing. He had been the doctor hired by the commissioners to visit sick laborers in the hospital. Since doctors in the that era often dabbled in other things to make money maybe Dr. May had access to lime that he could sell to the commissioners. But the lime he had may have been given to him when the hospital was in operation so he could make casts for laborers with broken bones.

The final item is most interesting of all. Gerry Holland or Jerry Holland was a free black hired at least by 1794 who worked as a laborer with the surveyors and then the masons and finally as the commissioners' servant. I don't think the "materials" hauled for his house were building materials but rather furniture and personal belongings that would make a small stone house vacated by stone workers habitable by Holland and perhaps his family.

Finally the man who did the hauling, Zepheniah Prater earned the commissioners' ire when he took back the slave he hired out to them. More on that, maybe, in another post. That Prater hired out a slave suggests that other slaves he owned helped him as he hauled materials.