How to buy the book

You can order at History Press as well as Amazon, Barnes and Noble and other on-line retailers. I will send you a signed copy for $23, a little extra to cover shipping. I will send you both Slave Labor in the Capital and Through a Fiery Trial for $40. Send a check to me at PO Box 63, Wellesley Island, NY 13640-0063.

My lectures at Sotterley Plantation in St. Mary's County, Maryland, on September 23, 2015, and the DAR Library on December 5 are now blog posts below listed under book talks. The talk I gave
at the Politics and Prose Bookstore on February 28, 2015, along with Heather Butts, author African American Medicine in Washington, was taped by the bookstore. Take a listen.
Showing posts with label masters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label masters. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Where did the slaves' masters live?

The letters of the commissioners are mum when it comes to slave hire. This all happened well before the era when governments constantly studied themselves to make the bureaucracy more efficient. There was hardly any bureaucracy: three commissioners told one man to hire slaves. So in their records, there is not even a hint at why almost a third of the slaves hired came from such a distance.
Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 28

While the commissioners didn't write letters discussing slaves they hired, there are receipts in the records and also a few letters from masters authorizing others to collect the wages of their slaves. When I did my research, I didn't copy those letters since generally payrolls had that information. Of course now I wish I had copied everything.

Fortunately, others have shared copies. The images below were taken from the US Capitol Historical Society website: http://www.uschs.org/exhibit/exhibit-freedoms-shadow/dchc_00.htm

Valuable as it is, the website, in my opinion, doesn't quite milk the documents for all their significance. The documents suggest how far away the masters lived. The first receipt below is signed by Middleton Belt for his own slave, Peter, hired out to the commissioners.



Belt was a contractor who did hauling for the commissioners, and lived, I am pretty sure, in Georgetown. Another master Joseph Forrest signed for his slaves.

 

His brother Uriah was a prominent Georgetown landowner. Henry Turner collected the money for his father Joseph's slaves.


Was Turner another Georgetown resident who just sent his son over to collect the money?

Other receipts show that some masters lived far away. Valentine Reintzell wrote from Chaptico, Maryland, about 50 miles down river on the border of Charles and St. Mary's counties authorizing Zephaniah King to collect the money.



King in turn wrote authorizing Matthew Kennedy.

The next receipt for James Hollingshead who hired out Abram and Charles shows that James H. Blake collected the money that the two slaves earned for Hollingshead. Blake also collected the money for slaves hired out by Susannah Johnson and Francis Wolf. Hollingshead later became an overseer of the laborers at the Capitol. So he was not rich master. But James Blake was a man of some repute.








James Blake became the mayor of Washington, appointed by President James Madison. Blake had strong Virginia connections and lived there before moving back to Washington to become mayor, or so my spotty research suggests. Most of the slaves hired to work on the public buildings came from Maryland. There was a common law tradition restricting hiring out slaves in another state for over a year, but I wonder if Blake might have been a middleman who eased Virginia masters' fears and brought their slaves to Washington.

Another receipt shows Thomas Baden collecting the money for James Stone




And here is an interesting letter I missed, from Stone to the commissioner's clerk, Thomas Johnson, Jr., authorizing Baden to collect the money (though Stone seems to misspell Baden's name.) I'm kicking myself for missing this letter, which was available on-line well before I wrote my book, because of this phrase Stone used, asking for the money for "my Peoples labor in the Public Service."




In my research, I have found "people" used to refer to both a gentleman's staff of servants and to a contractor's employees. It did not necessarily have racial overtones as in the spiritual "Let my People Go." In this case, it clearly refers to black slaves. Yet, of course, when the Founders wrote "We the People of the United States..." in the Constitution, they were not thinking of their slaves.

Saturday, January 2, 2016

Assessment of Improved Property in 1803

"At the end of the month 7 free workers were hired, including Ambrose Moriarty.
In 1799 Moriarty wrote a letter to the commissioners saying he wanted to buy a building lot. He introduced himself by saying "I have formerly been employed in attending masons and other work for the public." He did buy a lot and was on the city’s 1803 tax roll."
Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 97

In 1803 Moriarty owned an improved lot on Square 432 assessed for $1000. He obviously didn't rely entirely on his wages as a laborer to accomplish that. I don't know where I found this list back in 1990, or who compiled it. What is also interesting in the context of my book on the use of slaves is how few masters who hired out slaves are on the list. Most of those few on the list were also contractors or employees doing work for the commissioners like Samuel Smallwood and Bennett Fenwick.

The exception was Ignatius Boone who owned property in square 907 valued at $1100 hired out at least 4 slaves, Charles, Jacob, Lewis and Moses. My guess is that he moved to the city after he hired out the slaves, not while he did.











Tuesday, December 29, 2015

Small pox in the city and the hired slaves


When the brick-making contractor John Mitchell heard that Bennett Fenwick, whose slaves dug clay, was planning to “bring smallpox to the city” and inoculate members of his family, the commissioners’ hired slaves soon knew about it. A group of them approached the commissioners and asked to be inoculated against smallpox. The commissioners sent ten of them to the hospital and deducted the doctor’s fee for those inoculations from the wages sent to the slaves’ masters. We know the inoculation of “Negro Emmanuel” who worked at the Capitol cost his master Alexander Scott seventeen shillings and six pence. But the commissioners did suffer a loss. It took a patient several days to recover from inoculation, and that year, the commissioners had promised masters not to deduct wages for time not on the job if their slave was sick.
Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 139

The commissioners described the slaves who asked to be inoculated as "Slye's labourers." Slye was the overseer at the Capitol.  The note to Dr. Crocker, of which I don't have a copy to scan, made clear that the slaves asked for the inoculation. It was at "their request." A month after the March 5, 1795, order to Crocker, he was replaced on April 27 by Dr. Brown who was to get "$1.33 per head for all laborers engaged in public employment." In September 1795 the commissioners paid Dr. Brown $21 for inoculating laborers.

However, the commissioners made some sacrifice since inoculation entailed preparing the patient with medicine in hopes that when he was exposed to smallpox he would have an easy course of the disease, and, of course, while he was sick, he had to remain in isolation. The commissioners didn't penalize the master for the time the slave might have been in isolation. In their 1796 newspaper advertisement soliciting "120 good laborers", the commissioners offered masters $60 for the year, a place for the slave to lay his blanket, rations, and "attendance by a physician and no deduction for sickness."

The receipt below was made out to laborer Thomas Dixon whose slave Will was inoculated in 1797 at a cost to Dixon of $3.

Below that there is a 1795 letter to speculator/developer John Nicholson. In the second page his manager explains that work will be delayed 6 weeks because his joiners had to be inoculated.







Saturday, April 18, 2015

Who gets paid when there is no money?

"In November 1797, they had not paid their workers since September. With funds so scarce, Hoban's padding his salary thanks to his slaves' work may have angered free workers."
 Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 109

A major frustration of  my research was not finding any explicit statements of policy in regards to paying for hired slaves. In September 1797 the commissioners could not pay their workers. In the following letter they alerted Hoban at the White House and Hadfield at the Capitol and told them to tell the workers and then prioritized who would get paid first once money became available.

Obviously slave masters had the least need of the money. They had no current expenses for the upkeep of the slaves they hired out. The commissioners paid workers by the month. In the letter they give paying them priority over quarterly "salaries." At this time the master's of many hired slaves were paid every quarter. But "salaries" may have referred only to what supervisors, like Hoban and Hadfield, and the commissioners got paid. The letter also mentions "small debts to laborers and people residing at a distance." Did that refer to the shilling a day paid to slave sawyers and money owed to masters, many of whom lived outside of the city?

I am afraid that the root of my problem is that the commissioners, in this case William Thorton and Gustavus Scott simply did not have that firm a grasp of the work force and they were careful to only make generalizations. They rarely got down to specifics in their letters. But in November they did ban the hiring of slave carpenters. Since all who had been hired belonged to Hoban and his friends, I raise the possibility that the lack of money contributed to the commissioners banning the slave carpenters. Or put it this way in the context of this letter: despite being paid a quarterly salary, Hoban still was among those first in line to get paid because he received the money paid to the slaves he hired as carpenters. All speculation, of course, but I think looking at the issue from many angles helps us get a feel for what was going on.

In making the photocopy I cut off the bottom line of the first page below


Saturday, April 11, 2015

The commissioners' slave hire end-game

"Of course the slaves Mrs. Adams saw were not yearly hires from St. Mary's and Charles Counties. That was the old system. Shortly after ending that system, the commissioners realized they had gone too far and began hiring slaves on a piecemeal basis, for short terms and in small numbers compared to the old system."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, pages 155-156


In my book I focus on the systematic use of slave labor as playing an essential role in the building of the White House and Capitol which began in the summer of 1792 and ended by 1800. After clearing trees, moving and raising building stones and roofs were the slaves' essential service and they did that without causing much complaint and at little cost to the commissioners. After all the stone was raised on both the Capitol and White House, far fewer slaves were hired so that I think it fair to say that there work was no longer as essential. The 12 slaves Abigail Adams saw clearing rubbish in November 1800 were neither essential nor part of the slave hire system that entailed housing, feeding and providing medical care for slaves that the commissioners ended by 1800.

That said, the letter below suggests that the commissioners certainly did not share my view of the matter in the summer of 1800. In it they roundly condemn a master who "clandestinely" took away "a negro man" he had hired out to the commissioners on January 1.

As anyone who reads my book will see, I am skeptical of the posturing of the commissioners. Taken at face value the letter suggests that the commissioners kept an eye on the hired slaves. That is not likely. They had fired Elisha Williams who had hired slaves since 1792 and there is no evidence that the commissioners stooped to do what Williams had done for them. At his time the commissioners had lost control over much of the work to Secretary of the Navy Stoddert. Threatening to sue a man who had retrieved his slave was something still in their power and a way to show their importance.

The master was not in some far off plantation, but one of their contractors, a carter. His removing his slave could have been the upshot over a dispute over payment. But other than a receipt for his work which I share in another post, I have found out little about him save that the commissioners' did pay him for several months of slave hire in 1800, not for a whole year, and according to the 1800 census he may not have been counted as owning a slave when the census was taken. I say "may not" because while there was no Prather counted, Zephk Frather was marked as having no slave. Perhaps he sold his slave. Perhaps because the slave was hired out, Frather/Prather didn't claim ownership and avoided a tax on the slave.

The only other letter I found from the commissioners to a master who removed his slave, two slaves in that case, was markedly different. They were amenable as long as the master replaced the slaves. I share that letter in another post.

The commissioners in that earlier letter were more sure of themselves in part because they had so many slaves working for them and doing good work. In the letter to Prather, they were venting their spleen as they were losing control of the project and control over free workers who found Secretary Stoddert more sympathetic to their needs. Losing a hired slave when they had so few enraged them. Those large crews of slaves had been their way to check the demands of free workers.



Saturday, February 14, 2015

Free laborers and slaves hired by the month

The laborers hired by the year, principally slaves, were evidently not kept on payrolls. Their wage did not vary unless they were absent for over a week. As these 1796 payrolls for overseers and laborers show, overseers and free laborers were on payrolls and during the building season monthly hires, usually more free laborers than slaves, were added to the payrolls.

The March 1796 payroll lists three overseers, including John S. Slye, who was hired by the commissioners as a reward for bringing 30 hired slaves to the city. Obviously those slaves, paid by the year, are not on this monthly payroll. One of the two laborers on the payroll, Jeremiah Holland, was, I think, the laborer referred to in a 1795 note as "Jerry the black man." 


The April payroll is as spare as the one in March and Slye is not on it. My guess is that he left or was fired.


I copied the July and August 1796 payrolls for overseers and laborers which shows how the number of laborers swelled. Also two new overseers are listed: William White and Samuel Smallwood. The July payroll shows that laborers got a raise in the middle of the month from 60 Maryland shillings a month to 75. However in the spring of 1797 they would again make 60 shillings a month so the raise was probably an inducement to continue working during the hot months.

These payrolls do not segregate the free laborers paid by the month from the slaves. Although members of the same family did work together, usually men with the same second name listed together were slaves and that the last name they shared is the last name of the master. Unfortuntely,  many of the payrolls were bigger than the photocopy machine at the Archives so I did not always include the signature of the person who received the monthly wages.

In my book I list hired slaves, masters, black laborers and white laborers so there you can find my ideas on the status of all the men on these payrolls. Below the 1796 payrolls, I show a scanned photocopy of a May 1797 payroll showing how a master or his agent signed for the receipt of his slaves' wages. The two men listed with Burnes as the last name were slaves of James Burnes.






Wednesday, February 11, 2015

Higher wages for slave laborers 1800

"He soon had eight because the commissioners loaned them for two days to the contractor building the war department building just west of the White House."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 156

To be strictly accurate "He", namely the commissoners' overseer of laborers Samuel Smallwood, sent 8 slaves and Davey Smallwood to work at the war deparment. Davey was rated at 2 shillings 3 pence for a days work while the other 8 were rated at 4 shillings 6 pence. I haven't made up my mind about who exactly Davey was. There is another reading of the this "Return." Four were Bennett Fenwick's slaves and the others were free. However, in many other payrolls Antony is a slave belonging to Queen. Smallwood always listed slaves by their first name followed immediately by their master's last name.

The wage rate 4 shillings 3 pence a day works out to 117 shillings a month. In 1794 the rate for laborers was 45 shillings a month, then raised to 60 shillings in August 1795. So this is a good wage for the masters, but only for a couple days. Someone needs to take a closer look at wage rates in 1798, 1799 and 1800, and the demand for laborers. Perhaps the commissioners hiring slaves from places like St. Mary's and Charles counties for a year, which they did until 1799, depressed wage rates. Once the labor pool was limited to slaves belonging to contractor/slave dealers like Bennett Fenwick. The wage rate for laborers rose.

As I also mention in the book, page 152, President Jefferson noticed how hiring slaves by the year could depress wages by half, but yearly hires had to be fed, housed, provided with medical care which added to the cost of hiring them. Seen from the slave's viewpoint, I think the demise of the yearly hire system for manual labor (it continued for house servants) was good because it made it easier for slaves to hire themselves out for short term jobs and perhaps pocketing at least some of the wage themselves, though it is hard to imagine in this case that Fenwick's 4 slaves saw any of the money they earned.



Monday, December 22, 2014

Laborer Thomas Dixon and His Hired Slave Will

"the commissioners paid Thomas Dixon wages for being a laborer and paid him the wages of his slave Will at the same rate..."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 27

Most payrolls kept by the overseers that I've seen include both free and slave laborers. In the earlier payrolls, the "Negroes" are at the bottom. In latter payrolls there is no division but the wages of the slave laborers are received by others.

The scan below shows that in at least one case, both the master and his slave worked as laborers and earned the same wage though, of course, the master Thomas Dixon collected the money for Will. Dixon's name appears on other payrolls, for example: http://archivepayrolls.blogspot.com/2015/02/payroll-for-laborers-august-1796.html. 

In that 1796 payroll Dixon was paid by the month and made just over 3 Pounds Maryland money for working 22 days or the equivalent of almost $8 a month. So it is possible that when Dixon hired on as a yearly labor in 1797, he risked making less money. (If the monthly hires worked fewer days, he would have made more.) Perhaps the commissioners made Dixon's working by the year a condition for their hiring his slave Will.
 




I'll discuss the $3 deduction for Will's smallpox inoculation in another post.

Sunday, December 21, 2014

Ignoring a slave's last name

"Likely many of the slaves had both a first and last name, but only one hired slave was ever listed with both names in the commissioners' records."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 26.

On page 72 of my book I briefly tell how the master of a slave named Jack Fuller was desperate to get the money due to him for hiring out his slave. Save for the only woman slave hired, Catherine Green, none of the slaves listed in the commissioners' record was given a last name. Even when slaves were on payrolls for extra wages that they kept themselves, they were listed with one name and usually without their master's last name also noted.


Other slaves were named Harry, Dick, Moses and Charles so last names might have been helpful. Maybe none of the slaves had a last name, but in the one letter I found written to the commissioners or their employees about a hired slave, the slave's master used the slave's last name. As you see below, the master John Linton made a point to refer to his slave by his full name, Jack Fuller.
 

In a receipt in which the commissioners reimbursed Robert Brent, a manager at the quarry, for paying John Linton, Jack Fuller is listed as "Negro Jack."






Tuesday, December 16, 2014

Christmas 1794

As far as I could tell when I did research in the National Archives, overseers and foremen began consistently keeping payrolls and time roles in December 1794.  I photocopied all I could find for that month, time roles for laborers and stone carvers, and payrolls for stone cutters and carpenters.

According to the time role for laborers, the cook Thomas Smith and the overseer Bennett Mudd worked on Christmas Day, as well as a free laborer named Francis Smith. No one else worked that day. Everyone else was marked absent. Of course, time rolls give no idea if the meal Thomas Smith prepared on Christmas Day 1794 was in anyway different from what he usually did with the salt meat and Indian meal which was the laborers' and overseers' common fare.

But special or not, we learn something about the city in 1794 if we use the information we have to figure out who might have been around to partake of that Christmas dinner.

In conjunction with Obama's Inauguration in 2009, the National Archives shared a photograph of the time role of overseers and laborers at the President's house. It gives graphic evidence of the hired slaves working on the public buildings.



You can see the free workers on the top of the list and the hired slaves at the bottom. An "N" prefaces the slave's one name and the master's name comes after that. 

In doing this blog post, I stumbled on a good way to share this photo. I use the "original size" of the photo which, of course, doesn't fit into the neat dimensions of the blog. But you can scroll down and see the names of the free and slave workers at their actual size. Use the bottom bar on the blog and move it to the right and see which days the men worked. You can align the right edge of your device with "25 Thursday," Christmas Day, and see that for all but three men, it was a day off. You can also see who worked on Christmas Eve and who continued working after Christmas.




I used this time role as an illustration in Slave Labor in the Capital. It is a fundamental document about the founding of Washington. For one thing it shows that there was no work on Sunday. Work on that day was not even listed as an option. In my book, I pointed out how the information on it shows that most of the hired slaves stopped working a few days for Christmas. Their yearly hire was up. 

The few slaves who worked after Christmas likely had owners who lived nearby like Middleton Belt's Jack and James Claggett's George, The last day of three of Edward Plowden's slaves was the 22nd and they didn't work again in December. They were taken back by to St. Mary's County. (His slave named Arnold did work after Christmas. There is no telling why.)

There is another time role of the laborers for December 1794 kept by another overseer, Thomas Hardman. It shows the axemen and others who worked with the surveyors. The Archives didn't share a photo of that so a scan of a photocopy I took in 1989, when I collected documents as I researched my book Through a Fiery Trial, will have to do. There is no gap in the list between free and slaves workers, but again the slaves are marked with "N." 



Here is a close up of the portion of the time role listing the hired slaves. No one listed on that time role worked on Christmas Day.



Jerry Holland, the second name on the list below who was a free black, worked on Christmas Eve and then had 3 days offs. Scroll down from that mark on Christmas Eve and you can see that 4 hired slaves also worked then, including Peter, another of Middleton Belt's slaves. Five of the slaves had their last day on December 20th, including three of Edward Plowden's slaves who faced a long trip back to St. Mary's County. Seven of the free laborers worked on Christmas Eve.

Counting the men who worked on Christmas Eve and after Christmas, then Thomas Smith might have prepared Christmas dinner for 34 laborers including 14 hired slaves.

As far as I can tell from what records we have, the slave and free laborers worked together and ate together, or at least ate the same food. Payrolls show us another thing they shared. The free laborers were illiterate, too. When they signed for their pay, they made their mark instead, even the cook Thomas Smith.





That Christmas dinner probably included others. Another December time role that I photocopied was not so detailed. But it shows that at least one of the four stone carvers working at the President's house had to have worked after Christmas. He was marked for working 24 days. And another worked 22 1/2 days had to have been around too. (My photocopy cut off their first names, but they were all free, skilled workers and well paid.)




In 1794 Washington was little more than a work site. Hired laborers had to be fed and given a place to sleep. Slaves were hired from masters on that condition and free laborers did not make enough money to afford a home. Skilled workers who made two to three times as much money as the laborers were also given free housing. There is evidence that many of them got rations from the laborer's cook, though there is no record of how many were fed in December 1794. 

We also have the payroll of the carpenters at the President's house, and from that we can see that at least 11 of them were around on Christmas Day, including 5 slave carpenters. It would be more accurate to say two slave carpenters, Harry and Tom, and three teenage apprentices who earned just a bit more than laborers. These slaves belonged to James Hoban who superintended construction and Peirce Purcell who was the foreman at the site. Like all masters, they collected the wages of their slaves.




Then there were the stone cutters. It is fair to say all eyes were on them as they prepared the sandstone for setting at both buildings. There are 32 stone cutters listed in the December payroll. (When scanning the photocopy of this payroll that I made at the National Archives, the size of my scanner forced me to cut off 5 names: Thomas Barth, Frederick Necks, Thomas Dollar, George Jacob and David Waterston. Those 5 are listed in the appendix of Slave Labor in the Capitol where I list the names of slaves, their masters, as well as free workers.)




Of those 32 stone cutters, 20 worked enough days to suggest they were around on Christmas Day, though to suggest that skilled stone cutters would break bread with common laborers is pushing the spirit of Christmas a bit far. Then again, the laborers hauled the sandstone to the work sites. The stone cutters depended on them.

In my book, although all these documents informed my narrative, I don't mention Christmas Day 1794. But December 1794 might be a good starting point for another book about building the capital. That book could try to discover who all the men listed were and what became of them. But a key to learning more about these men is for the National Archives to photograph and share all the payrolls, time roles, and other documents, and put them on-line.