How to buy the book

You can order at History Press as well as Amazon, Barnes and Noble and other on-line retailers. I will send you a signed copy for $23, a little extra to cover shipping. I will send you both Slave Labor in the Capital and Through a Fiery Trial for $40. Send a check to me at PO Box 63, Wellesley Island, NY 13640-0063.

My lectures at Sotterley Plantation in St. Mary's County, Maryland, on September 23, 2015, and the DAR Library on December 5 are now blog posts below listed under book talks. The talk I gave
at the Politics and Prose Bookstore on February 28, 2015, along with Heather Butts, author African American Medicine in Washington, was taped by the bookstore. Take a listen.
Showing posts with label overseers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label overseers. Show all posts

Friday, December 18, 2015

The slave axe-men and their overseer

"The slaves worked as much under a man almost the opposite. James Dermott didn’t see them as an object of pity, but as a source of future profit. He worked behind the axe-men and surveyors and saw that the downed tree trunks were moved to the side of the street where the hands, probably slaves, of the original landowner would eventually cut up the trunks into cord wood for heat or burning brick kilns.... Commissioner Stuart, who hired him, had doubts that Dermott could handle slaves since he was just off the boat from Ireland. Indeed, while the slaves were doing familiar work, Dermott was learning on the job, learning about slavery. That Dermott showed he could handle slaves raised his standing with the commissioners, all slave holders. With the money he earned Dermott bought city lots, houses and slaves. Soon he also sold slaves especially girls ready to become servants to people who bought the houses he sold."
Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 56ff
 
Beginning with their fight with L'Enfant, the commissioners feuded with most of the men they hired to supervise the workers. In the correspondence generated by those feuds, we sometimes get a glimpse of the hired slaves, always as innocent bystanders. The commissioners effort to fire Andrew Ellicott, the surveyor hired by Jefferson and Washington in 1791, generated a thick file of letters. With much of the correspondence of President Washington on-line, there is no need for me to scan the photocopies I used when I wrote Through a Fiery Trail in 1990. However, the portion of the letter about Ellicott referring to slave axe-men is so short, I cut out that portion of it and scanned it below to lend the letter a bit authenticity.

You can find the complete letter here: http://founders.archives.gov/documents/Washington/05-15-02-0332  And here is the transcription of the portion I snipped:

Major Ellicott cannot but remember that more than once he spoke of Dermott as the readiest Calculator he had met with; and though in the Succeeding Summer he employed him wholly, or nearly so, as an Overseer to overlook the Negroes in cutting down the trees in the Streets and Avenues, previous to the Sale in the fall and preparatory to it, he employed him in calculating the Areas and dividing the Squares.
The Commissioners saw the impropriety of employing Dermott to overlook the cutting down the Avenues and Streets at his wages, and especially as he was an European, he had probably never had any thing to do of the kind: they perceived too, Dermotts uneasiness at his situation, and were glad to see that Ellicott had changed it.
Major Ellicott asserts that he communicated his intention to discharge Dermott, to Doctr Stuart who pointedly opposed his dismission—Doctr Stuart neither remembers or believes it—nor does Mr Johnson or Mr Carroll recollect they ever heard any thing of it. On some joyous Occasion, We believe on the laying a Stone of the Bridge, Dermott was in Liquor and in that State intimated to Doct. Stuart that there were inaccuracies in the work, but so far from a disposition to pick up Matter against Ellicott, Doctr Stuart let Dermott know, that he should take no notice of what he said unless he would at a more Seasonable time address himself to the Commissioners—Dermott did not and nothing more was done at that time—Not long afterwards as Ellicott said, he had discharged Dermott: and as Dermott said Ellicott told him, that there was no present business for him but to be ready against the Axmen should go to Work in the Spring
I think Thomas Johnson, the commissioner who was a lawyer, wrote the letter and he knew how to appeal to his old friend George Washington. I think Johnson exaggerated any awkwardness Dermott felt as he learned to handle slaves because that would alarm Washington who had spent a lifetime dealing with slave overseers. Dermott soon bought and sold slaves on his own account.






Tuesday, December 8, 2015

Hired slaves preparing the city in 1800

"Meanwhile in May, Smallwood placed an ad for 8 men good at ditching. It must have been a come down for a man who once supervised five times that many men. Shortly after placing that ad, Smallwood went to work at the Navy Yard where he could place ads for 30 to 40 men."


I photocopied this page of the commissioners' proceedings because of the order that the overseer of the laborers Samuel Smallwood "keep not less than four Labourers engaged in ditching and levelling..." That laborers, presumably hired slaves, did such work is not surprising, but that so few were assigned to do the job is remarkable. The distance between the White House and Capitol was over a mile, and there were more roads that needed ditching and leveling. This might be described as a token crew deployed to answer particular complaints, not a serious effort to see that the city had good streets with good drainage.





Friday, November 20, 2015

Who bossed the slaves Mrs. Adams saw?

Judging from the records, the commissioners finally addressed the problem of rubbish in September on the Capitol Square first. There a Captain Coyle was filling Capt. Elisha Williams shoes by overseeing the overseers, in this case just one overseer. Smallwood‘s first replacement didn‘t last long. Capt. Coyle needed a new one and the commissioners hired a Mr. Tippett who they hoped would do. They warned Coyle “it will be absolutely necessary that some industrious active man should be employed to push on the work,” and ordered him “to increase the number of laborers to twenty and the Carts to eight or ten at least.” On November 11, a few days before the First Lady arrived and two weeks before she wrote her letter quoted above, the commissioners wrote to Stoddert that they would have "an Overseer and twenty good Laborers" available to clean up the White House yard in "a few days."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 157 

In another post I quote the letter in which First Lady Abigail Adams sneered at the overseer of the slave laborers working in her yard http://capitalslaves.blogspot.com/2015/03/abigail-adams-amused-by-slaves-working.html. In the commissioners' letter below I think I found the name of that overseer, Mr. Tippett. In other records I've seen a Dyson Tippett listed.

I first thought these laborers were pavers, but since that work was done by contractors, I don't think that first impression was accurate. They were likely the crew cleaning up the grounds around the public buildings.

The description by Mrs. Adams and this letter allow us to draw some other conclusions. The commissioners referred to "laborers" and the First Lady saw only "slaves." That suggest that in 1800 white laborers could get better pay elsewhere, preparing the grounds for the Navy Yard for example.

Also, Tippett, the overseer, was himself overseen by a Captain Coyle. In 1799 the commissioners laid off Captain Elisha Williams the man who previously oversaw the overseers. Williams oversaw three overseers, maybe four at time, who, in turn, oversaw up to 120 laborers, at least 90 of them hired slaves. What Mrs. Adams saw was a shadow of the force the commissioners once commanded yet the note they sent to Captain Coyle seems more officious than anything they ever sent to Williams.



Monday, November 16, 2015

An overseer protests when slaves that he owns are dismissed

"Samuel Smallwood, the overseer of the laborers at the Capitol, began hiring out his own slaves by the month to work at the Capitol. In September 1797, in order to economize, the commissioners stopped monthly hires. Small complained to the commissioners."
Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 29
November 13, 1797
Hon. Gentlemen, I take the Liberty of presenting you a few lines concerning of my Labs that are wrought at the Capt [Capitol] by the month and now are discharged. Gentlemen, I hope you will take it in Consideration and Grant me that Liberty of taking them in again by the Month as I my Self are Employed by the month. If I can't prevail on you Gentlemen to take them in again, It will Certainly take my own Wages to Support them this winter as they are not one Days work to be had Gentlemen. Your Compliance will greatly Oblige your most Obedient Hum Servt
Saml N Smallwood
Captl Hill



A middleman in the slave hiring process becomes an overseer

"Middlemen soon got involved in the slave hire process. In November 1794, a month before the slave hire contracts were finalized at the first of the year, John Slye offered to bring thirty "valuable Negro men slaves" owned by friends on the condition that they get sixty dollars a year for each slave and the commissioners would hire Slye as an overseer."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 30

The letter below is from William Deakins who acted as the treasurer for the commissioners and also for the Potomac Company. He knew Slye from the Potomac company. Slye came to work for the company with recommendations as to his own character and with "hands." I don't think we can assume that those "hands" were slaves. Slye worked as an overseer at the Capitol for at least two years. I am not sure which slaves Slye brought to the Capitol but it might be possible to find out because those slaves asked the commissioners for inoculation against small pox and if they had been inoculuated, the payment to those masters would have been docked. 

Gentlemen
The bearer Mr. John S Slye wishes to be employed as an overseer in the city, and in order to get him into your employ, his friends, he says, have engaged to hire to the city thirty valuable Negro Men Slaves for one year at 60 dollars a year for each. Mr. Slye had letters of recommendation to me from Mr. Forbes and Mr. Southern. when I was director of the Poto[mac]. Company and he was employed for one year with twenty hands which he brought with him on the Potomac Company's works. If you have a vacancy for an overseer, it may be an object to get Mr. Slye with the number of Labourers he can bring, which he says are valuable slaves.
William Deakins, Jr.
Nov 14, 1794




Wednesday, March 11, 2015

More than a farm overseer: Smallwood's letter April 1, 1798

"Judging from a letter Samuel Smallwood wrote to the commissioners, he envied the slaves. He was vexed that he had to sweat over attendance sheets and payrolls after the bell rang marking the end of the work day."

Quote for Slave Labor in the Capital, page137

Perhaps "envied" is not the right word to use, but Samuel Smallwood's letters are open to many interpretations. He paints his job as a difficult one and because of that he deserves a raise.

In this letter he again harps on the lack of vegetables and bad food. The commissioners did give him a raise. He was a valuable employee. Unfortunately, the commissioners never wrote letters of commendation. It was beneath them. So in our effort to understand what he did we are left with the stilted prose of Smallwood and his stand for his due.

Instead of describing himself as overseer of hired slaves, he is in charge of "management of the Laboring Department." Did that pride in what he did rub off on the laborers, both yearly hires who were mostly slaves and the many whites who were monthly hires?

Washington, April 1st, 1798
Gentlemen, I once more take the liberty of presenting you a few lines in the following manner viz In the first place to shew you gentlemen that my wages are not ---- to the tasks that are confered upon me at the Capt building. The management of the labouring department has been under the direction of two overseers ever since the Capt began until the present season tho business appears as hard to manage as it ever was, but I conceive that I can do the hole business myself by using greater exertions which I always took a pleasure in doing for good of the public but Gentlemen I hope you will take this in to consideration and if you think my wages are adequate to this task after taking this in your consideration I will then rest in content. I hope Gentlemen will likewise consider my bad accommodations you may rest ashored that my living are very hard. It is said I have so much and Found but it cannot be cauld Found where there is only meat and bread alone - a man cant live on that where there is aplenty of other vigitibils and to have these things to buy out of my wages it reduces it to a mear nothing - Gentlemen if I did not think that I earned better wages I would not solicit you on this subject. I ever have done in all my power for the ---- of the Publick and I hope it will ever be my determination so to act. Its likely gentlemen you may think my wages are as great as and overseers can get on the country in a farm but a man in this place as myself have I suppose three times the hands to manage as and overseer on a farm. Likewise I have a great deal of troubel in making out return of the Labr and paying of the monthly labr that I do all of nights after bell rings which I hope you will gentlemen conceive that I am deserving of and addisionnal to my present wages. no more at present only remain your most obd & humb servt, Saml N Smallwood


Friday, March 6, 2015

Abigail Adams amused by slaves working at White House

"In November 1800, First Lady Abigail Adams stood at a window of the White House and saw a small gang of slaves clearing dirt and rubbish from her yard. In a November 28 letter to a friend in Massachusetts, she opined dismissively: 'I have amused myself from day to day in looking at the labor of 12 negroes from my window who are employed with four small Horse carts to remove some dirt in front of the house; the four carts are all loaded at the same time and whilst four carry this rubbish about a half a mile, the remaining eight rest upon their shovels; two of our hardy N. England men would do as much work in a day as the whole 12.'"

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 18




Work arrangements before slave hire

"The commissioners encouraged Williams to hire men who work by the job, not on time wages and expecting chocolate butter for breakfast...."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital page 42

One result of the commissioners firing L'Enfant's workers in January 1792 was that they had to find somebody to organize the work that had to be done and this time they would not give nebulous orders to proceed, as they did with L'Enfant. They tried to give explicit orders. That was difficult because they really didn't know how to go about such a huge and unprecedented project, unprecedented in this country at least.

I share the scans of two documents I photocopied from the microfilm reels of the commissioners' proceedings made by the National Archives. The first is the commissioners' contract with Elisha Williams who they put in charge of the work. The second is their instructions to Williams outlining what they wanted him to do after the commissioners' adjourned and left Georgetown.

I didn't crop the first scan to exclude other matters the commissioners dealt with. I am always accused of sharing too much detail in my books. Here's a chance to show the many details I didn't share.

Four months after hiring Williams, the commissioners instructed him to hire slaves. That raises the question: when they hired Williams did they already expect to hire slaves? Williams was to be the "overseer," be in charge of "provisions" for workers, prepare for brick making and get timber to build huts to get ready for work in the Spring. Another order asked him to get the huts built by Spring.

But he was to overseer of those laborers those "who do work on priced time." When the commissioners hired slaves, they hired them for a year. If they expected Williams to exclusively handle slaves, they might of simply said he would oversee yearly hires.

These documents show that the commissioners were not thinking of hiring slaves but trying to arrange that all the work be done on a piece-work basis. That is, they wanted him to contract with men who would dig clay for bricks or cut timber for huts for a certain price. (They soon instructed Williams to hire men on a piece work basis to build the huts.) The amount of time it took them to do it would have no bearing on what they were paid. Of course, this may have invited slave owners to bid for the job and use their slaves to do it but it would free the commissioners from having to hire workers paid by the days, month or year, free or slave.




Saturday, February 14, 2015

Free laborers and slaves hired by the month

The laborers hired by the year, principally slaves, were evidently not kept on payrolls. Their wage did not vary unless they were absent for over a week. As these 1796 payrolls for overseers and laborers show, overseers and free laborers were on payrolls and during the building season monthly hires, usually more free laborers than slaves, were added to the payrolls.

The March 1796 payroll lists three overseers, including John S. Slye, who was hired by the commissioners as a reward for bringing 30 hired slaves to the city. Obviously those slaves, paid by the year, are not on this monthly payroll. One of the two laborers on the payroll, Jeremiah Holland, was, I think, the laborer referred to in a 1795 note as "Jerry the black man." 


The April payroll is as spare as the one in March and Slye is not on it. My guess is that he left or was fired.


I copied the July and August 1796 payrolls for overseers and laborers which shows how the number of laborers swelled. Also two new overseers are listed: William White and Samuel Smallwood. The July payroll shows that laborers got a raise in the middle of the month from 60 Maryland shillings a month to 75. However in the spring of 1797 they would again make 60 shillings a month so the raise was probably an inducement to continue working during the hot months.

These payrolls do not segregate the free laborers paid by the month from the slaves. Although members of the same family did work together, usually men with the same second name listed together were slaves and that the last name they shared is the last name of the master. Unfortuntely,  many of the payrolls were bigger than the photocopy machine at the Archives so I did not always include the signature of the person who received the monthly wages.

In my book I list hired slaves, masters, black laborers and white laborers so there you can find my ideas on the status of all the men on these payrolls. Below the 1796 payrolls, I show a scanned photocopy of a May 1797 payroll showing how a master or his agent signed for the receipt of his slaves' wages. The two men listed with Burnes as the last name were slaves of James Burnes.






Saturday, January 24, 2015

Did the overseer have a staff?

I'm trying to share all of the payrolls I photocopied at the National Archives back in 1989 hoping the others can better interpret them than I can. The small payroll below puzzled me because I could not figure out how the days worked multiplied by the wage rate equals the wage paid. However, lying in bed one morning 5 months after writing the book, I think I figured it out: the 150 in line with Smallwood's name is the rate of pay for the month in shillings, so that Smallwood was promised 7 pounds, 10 shillings a month. But for that month he only received 7/4/2 because the 25 days work was not rated a full month and he was deducted 5/10 for one day less than the full 26 day month (30 days less 4 Sundays.) Strange way to keep track of things. I'll sleep on this some more.

Then as I kept looking at the payroll something else struck me. In 1798 Smallwood became the lone overseer in charge of the hired laborers, including the hired slave laborers. He had to work closely with the cook listed as Jean Short in this payroll. (Usually she was listed as Jane Short.) Could the four other men on the list have been assistants to the overseer and cook? Two of the men listed were probably hired slaves. Smallwood usually listed the master's last name directly after the slave's first name with the master signing for receiving the wages. In this payroll Jacob Clements signed for Henry Clemonds and Smallwood himself signed for James Deakins. I suggest that James was the slave of a master named Deakins. (There was a family of that name in Georgetown.) Finally in the last line of the payroll Smallwood receives money for ringing the work bell at the Capitol. The bell rang out when work began and when there were breaks for meals. Perhaps after Smallwood rang the bell, the four men, two of them slaves, helped distribute the meals from the cook.


Tuesday, December 16, 2014

Christmas 1794

As far as I could tell when I did research in the National Archives, overseers and foremen began consistently keeping payrolls and time roles in December 1794.  I photocopied all I could find for that month, time roles for laborers and stone carvers, and payrolls for stone cutters and carpenters.

According to the time role for laborers, the cook Thomas Smith and the overseer Bennett Mudd worked on Christmas Day, as well as a free laborer named Francis Smith. No one else worked that day. Everyone else was marked absent. Of course, time rolls give no idea if the meal Thomas Smith prepared on Christmas Day 1794 was in anyway different from what he usually did with the salt meat and Indian meal which was the laborers' and overseers' common fare.

But special or not, we learn something about the city in 1794 if we use the information we have to figure out who might have been around to partake of that Christmas dinner.

In conjunction with Obama's Inauguration in 2009, the National Archives shared a photograph of the time role of overseers and laborers at the President's house. It gives graphic evidence of the hired slaves working on the public buildings.



You can see the free workers on the top of the list and the hired slaves at the bottom. An "N" prefaces the slave's one name and the master's name comes after that. 

In doing this blog post, I stumbled on a good way to share this photo. I use the "original size" of the photo which, of course, doesn't fit into the neat dimensions of the blog. But you can scroll down and see the names of the free and slave workers at their actual size. Use the bottom bar on the blog and move it to the right and see which days the men worked. You can align the right edge of your device with "25 Thursday," Christmas Day, and see that for all but three men, it was a day off. You can also see who worked on Christmas Eve and who continued working after Christmas.




I used this time role as an illustration in Slave Labor in the Capital. It is a fundamental document about the founding of Washington. For one thing it shows that there was no work on Sunday. Work on that day was not even listed as an option. In my book, I pointed out how the information on it shows that most of the hired slaves stopped working a few days for Christmas. Their yearly hire was up. 

The few slaves who worked after Christmas likely had owners who lived nearby like Middleton Belt's Jack and James Claggett's George, The last day of three of Edward Plowden's slaves was the 22nd and they didn't work again in December. They were taken back by to St. Mary's County. (His slave named Arnold did work after Christmas. There is no telling why.)

There is another time role of the laborers for December 1794 kept by another overseer, Thomas Hardman. It shows the axemen and others who worked with the surveyors. The Archives didn't share a photo of that so a scan of a photocopy I took in 1989, when I collected documents as I researched my book Through a Fiery Trial, will have to do. There is no gap in the list between free and slaves workers, but again the slaves are marked with "N." 



Here is a close up of the portion of the time role listing the hired slaves. No one listed on that time role worked on Christmas Day.



Jerry Holland, the second name on the list below who was a free black, worked on Christmas Eve and then had 3 days offs. Scroll down from that mark on Christmas Eve and you can see that 4 hired slaves also worked then, including Peter, another of Middleton Belt's slaves. Five of the slaves had their last day on December 20th, including three of Edward Plowden's slaves who faced a long trip back to St. Mary's County. Seven of the free laborers worked on Christmas Eve.

Counting the men who worked on Christmas Eve and after Christmas, then Thomas Smith might have prepared Christmas dinner for 34 laborers including 14 hired slaves.

As far as I can tell from what records we have, the slave and free laborers worked together and ate together, or at least ate the same food. Payrolls show us another thing they shared. The free laborers were illiterate, too. When they signed for their pay, they made their mark instead, even the cook Thomas Smith.





That Christmas dinner probably included others. Another December time role that I photocopied was not so detailed. But it shows that at least one of the four stone carvers working at the President's house had to have worked after Christmas. He was marked for working 24 days. And another worked 22 1/2 days had to have been around too. (My photocopy cut off their first names, but they were all free, skilled workers and well paid.)




In 1794 Washington was little more than a work site. Hired laborers had to be fed and given a place to sleep. Slaves were hired from masters on that condition and free laborers did not make enough money to afford a home. Skilled workers who made two to three times as much money as the laborers were also given free housing. There is evidence that many of them got rations from the laborer's cook, though there is no record of how many were fed in December 1794. 

We also have the payroll of the carpenters at the President's house, and from that we can see that at least 11 of them were around on Christmas Day, including 5 slave carpenters. It would be more accurate to say two slave carpenters, Harry and Tom, and three teenage apprentices who earned just a bit more than laborers. These slaves belonged to James Hoban who superintended construction and Peirce Purcell who was the foreman at the site. Like all masters, they collected the wages of their slaves.




Then there were the stone cutters. It is fair to say all eyes were on them as they prepared the sandstone for setting at both buildings. There are 32 stone cutters listed in the December payroll. (When scanning the photocopy of this payroll that I made at the National Archives, the size of my scanner forced me to cut off 5 names: Thomas Barth, Frederick Necks, Thomas Dollar, George Jacob and David Waterston. Those 5 are listed in the appendix of Slave Labor in the Capitol where I list the names of slaves, their masters, as well as free workers.)




Of those 32 stone cutters, 20 worked enough days to suggest they were around on Christmas Day, though to suggest that skilled stone cutters would break bread with common laborers is pushing the spirit of Christmas a bit far. Then again, the laborers hauled the sandstone to the work sites. The stone cutters depended on them.

In my book, although all these documents informed my narrative, I don't mention Christmas Day 1794. But December 1794 might be a good starting point for another book about building the capital. That book could try to discover who all the men listed were and what became of them. But a key to learning more about these men is for the National Archives to photograph and share all the payrolls, time roles, and other documents, and put them on-line.






Thursday, December 4, 2014

Naismith to the Commissioners August 14, 1796

"...no idea why, given that background, he had been made an overseer."


quote from Slave Labor in the Capital page 137:



Imagine Isaac Naismith's shock when his recommendation from General John Davidson, prominent member of the Executive Council of the State of Maryland, for a job on the team building the nation's capital resulted in his being hired as an overseer of laborers, most of them hired slaves, at the President's house. Worse still, he was paid so little he couldn't support himself and his small family.

Despite the educated hand writing the letter, it is difficult to read but it is clear that he thought being an overseer was quite a let down given his education and 11 years of work experience.

A few months later Naismith complained that he was not making enough to support his family and asked permission to supplement his income by "keeping a small set of books" for another concern which would only take two days a week.. In 1797 the commissioners had two overseers at the Capitol and judging from Naismith's letter, two at the White House. Naismith argues that one overseer can attend to the laborers and issue rations and that he, the other overseer, will still be able to take care of accounts and receipts for materials. 




Saturday, November 29, 2014

March 1797 payroll for overseers and laborers at the Capitol

"Samuel Smallwood, the overseer of slaves at the Capitol, began hiring out his own slaves to work by the month at the Capitol."

Quote from Slave Labor at the Capital, page 29


This is a copy of the top portion of a photocopy of a March 1797 payroll for overseers & laborers. It is one of the most difficult documents to interpret.

Unlike earlier payrolls, none of the hired slaves are listed with an "N" either before or after the name. Although many slaves had last names they were never used in the commissioners' records. We get an indication that a laborer is a slave if that man did not sign for his monthly wages. For example. John Dorin signed for his 3 pounds 2 shillings and 3 pence, almost $8. The overseer Samuel Smallwood signed for and evidently received the wages of Randolph Smallwood which suggests that Randolph was his slave. It is possible that Randolph was an apprentice but there are other references to Smallwood hiring out slaves and none to his hiring out apprentices.

Samuel Smallwood also signs for the wages of Peter Owen which suggests that Peter was the slave or apprentice of a man named Owen. He signs for 9 more laborers. The other overseer James Hollingshead signs for 6 evidently 4 were his own slaves.


Monday, November 17, 2014

Overseer assaulted, threat of whipping, because of ethnic tensions June 5,1798

After he reported that he was assaulted by an Irish carpenter, Smallwood worried "how do I know a certain class of peopel may entice even the blackis to commit depredations on me."

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital, page 137

The quote in the quote from my book is taken from a June 5, 1798, letter that the overseer of the laborers at Capitol Hill, Samuel Smallwood, wrote to the commissioners.As you can see below my photocopy of this unique letter is a poor one, especially the first page, so I'll try my best to transcribe it.
 Gentlemen, As I have ever endeavored to serve you and the public, I have ever expected to be treated in a decent manner by all those in the publick works. Instead of which I have been shamefully insulted by a Robert Aull a carpenter lately being here. The circumstances I shall relate to you. Just as the first day Mr. Aull came here he asked me if I would let him have my roome, one that I have for a boy to stay in to be convenient to ring the bell. I told him I co[u]ld not spare it by now meanes. Then he observed to me he did not come hear by his own desire or wish but there was a scheme in his coming which alarmed me verry much. I enformed Mr. Hadfield what Mr. Aull had said. Mr. Hadfield thought it proper to ask him what the expression meant which wordes Mr. Aull denied saying, but nothing was said to me until last Wednesday evening when Mr. Aull attacted me in a vile fation. my reply was to him that he had said so and so which he told me I was a dammed rascal and whip me he would and a number of other insulting language. with I walked from him and told him to mind his business and did not notis him. He followed me and struck me and then I turned to him an struck him several blows in my defens...[I have trouble with the last line]



The scenes the letter describe took place at the climax of the crisis between the young English architect George Hadfield and the Irish carpenter, led by Redmond Purcell, over how to frame and finish the roof of the Capitol. It was at this time, May 1798, that the Polish tourist Julian Niemcewicz visited the Capitol and opined that "the Negroes alone work." The scheme mentioned in the letter was the effort to get the commissioners to replace Hadfield with James Hoban which soon happened.

Smallwood's letter ends with his fear that the Irish faction would enlist the support of the "blackis" presumably the hired slaves who like Smallwood were housed on Capitol Hill.


I found no reply from the commissioners which might have made clear who the "blackis" were.

The commissioners, Gustavus Scott, William Thornton and Alexander White were never close to the workers which probably accounts for Smallwood making clear that he lived on Capitol Hill. That he needed the commissioners to arrange protection for him because his "Dew attention" was needed at the Capitol could be construed that other slaves might do the attacking while he tried to keep those he oversaw in line. As it turned out, there was no attack so we'll never know. It is possible that Smallwood really did not feel threatened and suggested it to prompt action from the commissioners because such an occurrence would reflect badly on their slave hire system.

The letter also gives a feel for what Capitol Hill was like at night. It was empty enough so that there could be a fight between an overseer and another employee and no one else seemed to notice it. Smallwood offered no witnesses. But it was crowded enough so a "roome" where the boy who rang the work bell slept could become a bone of contention. Perhaps Smallwood feared that Aull's scheme was to get close to the bell at night so he could ring it and summon the slaves to aid an Irish take over of the works!

In the dispute between the Irish and Scottish stone masons, the commissioners sided with the Irish. The ruling class then valued the Irish not as the best workers, but the cheapest. Smallwood worked for the commissioners for another two years. Robert Aull worked through 1798.

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Overseer Smallwood complains about meals

 "salt meat for brexfast, dinner and supper..." 

Quote from Slave Labor in the Capital page 133 referring to the March 7, 1797, letter from Samuel Smallwood to the Commissioners:

Commissioners of the City of Washington, Gentlemen,
In Consideration of my past Services and present ------, I take the Liberty of presenting you a few Lines to give you and Information of my Dissatisfaction for the same in the first instant relating to my Diet which are nothing more than Salt meat for Brexfast Dinner and Supper which is neither palitabel nor Constitutional and to bye tea Sugar and other Vegitables out of Fifteen Dollars you must reasonably suppose Gentlemen will reduce that to a mear nothing and Fifteen Dollars Gentlemen suppose it to be in truly Clear is not an Object to Induce a man to take on him Self the Cares troubles and Confindments that I have on me which Causes me to take the liberty of Informing the Hon Board that I am not therewith Content which I am willing to Still remain for twenty Dollars per month which I hope Gentlemen you will allow me I hope Gentlemen you will receive the above as a most respectful Detail of matter hear with me and give it your most sincere Consideration and Dispense to me as soon as Justice to the Publick and Satisfaction to your most Obt. Sert. Saml N Smallwood March 7, 1797



One advantage to putting source documents on line is I get to read them again. I realize now that I misquoted Smallwood. He wrote "brexfast" not "breakfast."

In the book, I use this letter to establish that white laborers and overseers got the same rations as the slaves. The letter also shows that Smallwood had only a basic education. In another letter he complains about the time it takes him to keep the payroll for laborers in order. That suggests to me that when he complains of his "cears, troubels and confindments", he was not complaining about the difficulty of getting the laborers to work, but how difficult it was for him to keep accounts of their labor. He had four different categories of laborers to manage: slaves hired by the year, slaves hired by the month, and free laborers hired by the year and month.